Herozite is a digital marketing agency in San Juan, Puerto Rico. We build websites, grow search traffic, and run campaigns for businesses in Puerto Rico and across the US.

Latest from the blog

Av. de Diego, Puerto Nuevo, San Juan

+1 (787) 605-7114

herozitesolutions@gmail.com

Illustration of connected page cards linked by lines, one highlighted in yellow

Does Google Discount Reciprocal Links? What the Rules Say Now

, ,

Web Design, SEO, Local SEO, PPC Management, Social Media Marketing, Conversion Optimization, Content Strategy

Illustration of connected page cards linked by lines, one highlighted in yellow
Reciprocal links and Google: what’s allowed Link exchange rules: A↔B reciprocal link; 3 rel values; 2 manual actions; 2 wk 2022 rollout. Paid or traded link?: rel="sponsored".

Quick answer

No, Google does not throw out every reciprocal link. Its spam policies name “excessive link exchanges” and partner pages built only for cross-linking as link spam. A supplier linking to you while you link back to the supplier is a normal part of the web, and Google does not treat that single relationship as a problem.

The risk starts when trading links becomes a tactic. If you swap links with sites you have no real tie to, or accept money, products, or services for a link, Google wants that link qualified with rel=”sponsored” or rel=”nofollow”. Its SpamBrain system is built to spot sites buying links and sites that exist to pass links.

  • Fine: Two-way links between real partners, clients, vendors, or local organizations that readers would find useful.
  • Risky: Link swap emails, “partner” pages full of unrelated sites, and three-way trades designed to hide the pattern.
  • Fix: Qualify any link that was paid for or traded with rel=”sponsored” or rel=”nofollow”, and remove the rest of a swap scheme.

The old version of this idea, that “Google now discounts all reciprocal links,” has been passed around SEO forums for years. It was never quite right. Google’s written policy goes after links made primarily to manipulate rankings, and a reciprocal link can be either honest or manipulative depending on why it exists.

Here is how to tell the difference, what Google’s own documents say, and how to clean up a site that has done some link trading in the past. If you want the broader question of whether bad links pointing at you can do damage, we cover that in can inbound links hurt your rankings.

What counts as a reciprocal link

A reciprocal link is simply two sites linking to each other. Site A links to site B, and site B links back to site A. It happens naturally all the time. A wedding photographer links to the venues she works at, and the venues list their preferred photographers. A San Juan accounting firm links to the chamber of commerce, and the chamber’s member directory links back.

The SEO version is different. Someone emails you a template that says “I’ll link to you if you link to me,” usually from a site you have never heard of in a niche that has nothing to do with yours. That is a link exchange, and it is the pattern Google’s spam policies describe.

What Google’s spam policies actually say

Google’s spam policies for Google web search define link spam as “creating links to or from a site primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings.” The examples list includes “Excessive link exchanges (‘Link to me and I’ll link to you’) or partner pages exclusively for the sake of cross-linking.”

Two words in that line do a lot of work: excessive and exclusively. Google is not saying a two-way link is spam. It is saying a pattern of trades, or a page that exists only to hold traded links, is spam. The same policy also lists buying or selling links that pass ranking credit, including exchanging “goods or services for links,” which covers a lot of informal trades such as “write us a review and we’ll link to you.”

The policy also says buying and selling links is “a normal part of the economy of the web for advertising and sponsorship purposes.” Those links are fine as long as they are qualified with rel=”nofollow” or rel=”sponsored”.

How Google finds link trades

Google says it detects policy violations “both through automated systems and, as needed, human review.” When it announced its December 2022 link spam update, Google said SpamBrain can “detect both sites buying links, and sites used for the purpose of passing outgoing links,” and that the update would take about two weeks to roll out, according to Search Engine Land’s report on the update. When those links are neutralized, whatever ranking value they were passing is gone.

That last part matters more than any penalty. For most small sites, a link swap does not trigger a dramatic drop. It just quietly stops counting, so the hours spent arranging it were wasted.

When it becomes a manual action

Human reviewers can also apply a manual action. Google’s Manual Actions report help page lists two link-related actions. “Unnatural links to your site” is for patterns of manipulative links pointing at you. “Unnatural links from your site” is for paid or traded links going out, and the page names excessive link exchanges as an example. The fix it gives for outbound links is to remove them or stop them from passing PageRank, for example with nofollow.

Safe and risky reciprocal links compared

Most real cases fall into one of these rows. The question to ask is always the same: would this link exist if search engines did not?

Reciprocal link risk spectrum. The question to ask: would this link exist if search engines did not? Low risk: a vendor or partner you work with links to you and you link back, leave it as a normal link; a local association, chamber, or sponsor listing, normal link with rel="sponsored" if you paid. Medium: a client’s “website by” footer credit on many sites, use your brand name as the anchor and consider nofollow on large networks. High: a cold email offering a swap from an unrelated site, decline it; a partners page that only holds traded links, remove it or qualify every link; a three-way trade, avoid it; a free product or service for a link, ask for rel="sponsored".
SituationRisk levelWhat to do
Vendor or partner you actually work with links to you and you link backLowLeave it as a normal link
Local association, chamber, or sponsor directory listing with a link backLowNormal link; use rel=”sponsored” if you paid for the listing
Client links to you in a “website by” footer creditMedium if it appears on many sitesMake sure the anchor is your brand name; consider nofollow on large networks
Cold email offering a link swap from an unrelated siteHighDecline it
“Resources” or “Partners” page that only holds traded linksHighRemove the page or qualify every link
Three-way trade (A links to B, B links to C, C links to A)HighAvoid; it is still a link exchange
Free product or service given in return for a linkHigh unless qualifiedAsk for rel=”sponsored” on the link

Footer credits deserve a note. Google’s policy separately lists “widely distributed links in the footers or templates of various sites.” A web designer with a credit on 40 client sites, all using keyword anchor text, fits that description. A plain brand name credit is far less of a concern, and anchor text choice is its own topic covered in why anchor text in backlinks matters.

How to use rel attributes on traded or paid links

Google’s guide to qualifying outbound links gives three values:

  • rel=”sponsored”: Ads, paid placements, and links given in exchange for money, products, or services. Google says nofollow is still acceptable here, but sponsored is preferred.
  • rel=”ugc”: Links in comments, forum posts, and other user-generated content.
  • rel=”nofollow”: Cases where the other two do not fit and you do not want to vouch for the linked page.

You can combine values with a space, such as rel=”ugc nofollow”. Google says links with these attributes “will generally not be followed,” which is the point: the link still works for visitors, and it stops passing ranking credit. If a partner insists on a followed link as a condition of a deal, treat that as a red flag.

Reciprocal link do’s and don’ts

DoDon’t
Link to partners, suppliers, and organizations your customers would care aboutAnswer “link exchange” emails from sites you don’t know
Use rel=”sponsored” on any link you paid for or traded goods forBuild a “Partners” page whose only job is to hold swapped links
Keep partner anchor text to the business nameAsk partners for exact-match keyword anchors
Check that a linking site is real, current, and relevant to your businessJoin three-way or ring trades meant to disguise reciprocity
Earn links with useful pages people want to citeRequire a link back in a contract without letting the site qualify it
Review your outbound links once or twice a yearAssume old swaps are harmless because nothing happened yet
Remove or qualify old swap links when you find themPanic and nofollow every outbound link on your site

Audit your reciprocal links in 30 minutes

  1. In Google Search Console, open the Links report and export Top linking sites.
  2. Crawl your own site with a tool such as Screaming Frog and export every external outbound link.
  3. Put both lists in a spreadsheet and match domains that appear in both. Those are your reciprocal links.
  4. For each match, write down why the relationship exists: client, vendor, sponsor, association, or swap.
  5. Mark any link that involved payment, free product, or a swap request. Add rel=”sponsored” to your side and ask the other site to do the same.
  6. Delete outbound links to sites that are unrelated, abandoned, or full of other swapped links.
  7. Check Search Console’s Manual Actions report. If it lists an unnatural links action, fix every affected link before requesting review.

Earn links that hold up

The links that keep working are the ones you didn’t have to trade for. Local guides, original data, and pages that answer a question better than anyone else in your market get cited without a swap. Our walkthrough on how to create SEO content is a good place to start. Our search engine optimization services include link audits and cleanup, and our content marketing strategy work focuses on pages worth linking to. If you are not sure whether past link trading is holding your site back, tell us about your site and we will come back with a plan.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Are reciprocal links bad for SEO?

Not by themselves. Google’s spam policies target excessive link exchanges and partner pages built only for cross-linking. Two businesses that genuinely work together and link to each other are doing what links are meant for.

Does Google penalize link exchanges?

It can. Google lists excessive link exchanges as link spam, and its systems can neutralize those links so they pass no value. In more serious cases, a reviewer can apply an “Unnatural links” manual action that you will see in Search Console.

Should I add nofollow to every outbound link to be safe?

No. Google’s link best practices say to use nofollow when you don’t trust a source, not on every external link. Use rel=”sponsored” for paid or traded links, rel=”ugc” for user content, and leave normal editorial links alone.

Do three-way link trades get around the rules?

No. A trade where site A links to B, B links to C, and C links back to A is still a link exchange made to manipulate rankings. It falls under the same spam policy, and SpamBrain is built to find sites that exist to pass links.

What should I do if I traded links in the past?

List the swapped links, then remove them or add rel=”sponsored” or rel=”nofollow” on your side. Ask partner sites to do the same on theirs. If Search Console shows a manual action, fix every listed issue and document the cleanup in a reconsideration request.

Want help putting this into practice? Let’s talk

Contact form

    By sending this form, you agree that we may contact you about your request. See our Privacy Policy.